Why women are hesitant to report abuse?
by. William Walker Jr
October 19, 2018
Weeks ago the nation was wrapped up in the confirmation hearings of Brett Kavanaugh. Then he was the supreme court nominee of Donald Trump. Like most decisions by this President not a choice without controversy. During his confirmation hearing Mr. Kavanaugh had been accused of sexual assault, by one of his former high school classmates. Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, had come forward to accuse Judge Kavanaugh. The process descended into a partisan fight, with those of the Republican party leaping to the defense of Judge Kavanaugh, and the Democratic party doing everything to discredit him and support Dr. Ford. Credibility stood at the center of the matter, which person was more credible with their account. This post isn't actually about the confirmation process, but a question that arose from it. This is a question that pertains to women who've been victims of assault. That question was: "Why didn't you report the crime?"
Those that wanted to attack or discredit Dr. Ford's testimony were quick to state well why are you now coming forward? Why didn't you say anything before now? Those that asked those questions seemed to ignore the fact that Dr. Ford had come forward with her accusations against Judge Kavanaugh before he was even the pick for nominee. Also she named him back in 2012 when having couples therapy. But this isn't anything new to victims of sexual assault. Often times they face some form of interrogation and questions to the validity of their claim. I myself have been guilty of the mindset of why didn't the woman say something before, how can you not report when someone assaults you? Like most men it's hard to understand a woman's plight. I'm not alone, most people when putting themselves in another's shoes at times can't empathize. We often go "Well if that was me I would've done it this way" not truly understanding or being able to relate to the situation. It's this attitude that plays into a victim's hesitancy in report.g the crime. I had two conversations that helped my understanding of this matter.
First conversation took place with my wife when watching news coverage on the hearing. I voiced the common question why do women not report assaults? My wife sweetly responded "for the same reason you didn't bring up issues with your manager to HR". You see at my last job I had major issues with my manger. He wasn't professional, there were a ton of issues I had with his management style. Others had recommended I discuss the issue with Human Resources. My hesitancy was rooted in zero faith with the department. I've never felt that in corporate America that the HR department was ever an advocate for the employee much more so for the Company, that is a topic for another day. The point is eventually I did bring up the issues with the HR department and after having a conversation with the HR manager, who's best advice to my problems was to I'll paraphrase "get over it". At one point I was advised told to speak to a therapist in regard to how I should deal with the stress of the job and how to accept the situation. I came away from the experience like what was the point? The manager's conduct remained the same and if anything I felt like there was now a target on my back. This is a feeling that plenty of women understand all too well. This brings me to the second conversation I had, which was with my father. I was talking to him about the conversation I had with my wife and how it made more sense to me why women wouldn't report abuse. For decades women's accusations and reports would fall upon deaf ears. My Dad said that was mainly due to the society the attitude that persisted as he was growing up which was in the sixties and seventies. He could recall often times when women would be chased down the street naked in his neighborhood by their abusive spouses or boyfriends. With people in the neighborhood looking the other way. The culture turned a blind-eye to a woman's plight if one actually did report a crime they were put through the ringer, while the perpetrator would either get a slap on the wrist or face no punishment at all.
The Me Too movement has created a cultural shift within this country. For once women's voices are being heard and taken seriously. Yet even though there appears to be this shift the same issues they faced before are still prevalent. While women may feel better about reporting allegations of abuse they still face demonizing attacks or in-action. Dr. Ford has faced a bevy of attacks due to her report while being ridiculed by the most powerful man in the country. The fact that Brett Kavanaugh's confirmation was barely delayed screamed to the public "What was the point?". Other women witness this and they've been witnessing results like this throughout this country's history. I recall the disappointment I felt when my call to HR resulted in nothing happening, and the paranoia of feeling like at any moment I would feel retribution from my manager. Again this is a feeling that women know all too well and repeatedly they witness how victims are attacked in a multitude of ways and the assaulter typically doesn't face such wrath.
Sadly not enough empathize or relate their situation to these victims. When harassment and assault has been so prevalent for years with the results typically being the same, it almost makes you question why would woman come forward at all? It also makes more sense on why the Me Too movement has been so powerful. It's almost as if the dam of holding back justice for women has burst and a torrent is consuming all in its path. That is a good thing there can be some downside to this sudden rush but again a topic for another day. If you've ever voiced the question "why didn't she report it or say something sooner?". Look through the history of how women have been treated in this country. It's up to us to further shift the attitude and encourage and protect more women to where they can feel like something will be done, and they'll get an answer to their own constant question of "What's the point?".